Five months, 117 applications, and what the federal employment numbers miss about looking for work in the current job market.
By Michael W. Hoskins
Independent Journalist & Editor, MWH Media
Nov. 17, 2026
My job search lives in a spreadsheet.
As of mid-November, that spreadsheet shows 117 applications submitted over five months, since a corporate restructuring eliminated my longtime editorial role.
Just 47 of them, about 40%, have led to formal rejections. Most of the rest have vanished into a black hole with no interview, no rejection, and no word beyond an automated confirmation receipt.
Behind those rows of data is me: a late 40-something with a quarter-century career in journalism and editorial leadership, including more than 14 years in digital health content and more than a decade at my last company. Since then, I've been neck-deep in this job market, navigating endless applications, occasional referrals, and multiple rounds of interviews. Yet here I am, heading toward the holidays without a permanent job.
My spreadsheet tracks the applications, but it doesn’t count the hours spent tailoring résumés and writing and rewriting cover letters, preparing for interviews, or wondering whether a promising conversation will lead anywhere.
I’m hardly alone.
The latest federal employment report offers some encouraging news. But it also shows how people can spend months looking for work in a labor market that is still adding jobs.
Employers and recruiters describe being overwhelmed with applications, making it harder for qualified candidates to get noticed. Even some people who already have jobs feel unable to leave. In a Resume Now survey of more than 1,000 full-time U.S. workers, 60% said financial fears, perceived skill gaps, and professional uncertainty left them feeling trapped and unfulfilled in their current jobs.
Automated screening and AI tools can add another complicating layer between applicants and hiring managers, leaving candidates trying to figure out how to get their experience in front of an actual person.
It's a dysfunctional job market, even when the headline economic numbers suggest otherwise.
Job market doesn't feel as healthy as it looks
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ October 2026 employment report released Nov. 6, offered some encouraging news.
Employers added 165,000 jobs during October, considerably higher than the previous 12-month average of 48,000 jobs per month. The unemployment rate changed little, at 4.1% compared to 4.2% in September.
But looking further into the report, the picture becomes more complicated as it digs into the reality of what so many people are experiencing in this job market:
- Longer unemployment: The average duration of unemployment climbed to 27.1 weeks in October, up from 24.8 weeks in September. That amounts to an average of more than six months without work. The median duration was considerably shorter, at 11.9 weeks, showing how longer unemployment spells pull the average higher.
- Months without work: About 2 million Americans had been unemployed for 27 weeks or longer, representing 27.6% of all unemployed workers.
- Fewer hours: The number of people employed part time for economic reasons rose by 339,000 to 4.8 million. These are workers whose hours were reduced or who couldn't find full-time employment.
- Uneven hiring: Professional and business services, healthcare, and transportation and warehousing helped drive October's job gains. But employment in the information sector, which includes journalism and digital publishing, showed little change.
The broader U-6 unemployment measure, which includes certain underemployed workers and people marginally attached to the labor force, also rose to 7.9%.
The headline unemployment rate doesn’t tell the whole story of people struggling to find full-time roles as the next chapter in their careers.
People who have stopped actively looking because they’re discouraged generally aren’t counted as unemployed. Those taking on freelance or part-time work to pay the bills generally count as employed, even if they’re still searching for a permanent, full-time job.
Running out of unemployment benefits doesn’t remove someone from the count. People without work who remain available and actively searching can still be counted as unemployed, whether they receive benefits or not.
But being counted as employed and finding the work you need are two different things.
Federal data also can't capture the everyday frustrations of navigating hiring processes, waiting weeks for decisions, or reaching the final interview stage only to hear nothing.
A recent Wall Street Journal podcast described the job market as being in a "deep freeze." Unemployment is still relatively low, but companies are hesitant to hire and people who have jobs are staying put.
Reporter Lindsay Ellis spoke with 100 job seekers across all 50 states and heard the same frustrations over and over: automated screening, endless applications, and employers who never get back to them.
Between economic uncertainty, AI reshaping how companies work and hire, and employers holding out for the perfect candidate, it’s not hard to see why the job market can look healthy on paper but feel very different when you’re trying to find work.
With the holidays approaching, many of us searching for a full-time role are likely also wondering how many of the decisions we’re waiting on will materialize before the end of the year.
Anatomy of my job search spreadsheet
My own spreadsheet reads like a microcosm of that bottleneck.
- 117 job applications between June 1 and Nov. 16, 2026.
- 47 have resulted in formal rejections.
- Of the other 70, most never got responses beyond an automated confirmation receipt.
- 3 led to an interview and then silence.
- 1 led to a scheduled final interview, but then ran into a corporate shift that put the role on hold until 2027 if not indefinitely.
The spreadsheet also tells the story of how my approach has evolved.
- My first 56 applications, submitted during the summer, were part of what I call the "spray and pray" phase. I applied broadly to positions that appeared to fit my experience, hoping that my background in journalism, editorial leadership, and digital content strategy would get some traction.
- There were a few hits and a couple of interviews. But most went nowhere.
- Some rejections arrived within hours, leaving me wondering whether anyone had actually reviewed my résumé, writing samples, or cover letter. Automated rejections aren't necessarily evidence that AI made the decision, but they certainly don't offer much insight into how an application was evaluated.
In August, I overhauled my résumé and digital portfolio, making my experience and published work easier to navigate. I also became more strategic about networking, pursuing internal referrals and focusing on opportunities that aligned more closely with my experience.
The search became more focused as I optimized how I was marketing myself, even if it didn’t become more predictable.
- I've leveraged about a dozen internal referrals and developed more direct conversations with editors, hiring managers, and recruiters.
- While only about a quarter of my post-August applications were heavily targeted, those efforts helped shift the results.
- Initial interviews for 8 roles, with 5 progressing into second or late stage interviews.
- Three late-stage hiring decisions remain hanging in the balance as Thanksgiving approaches.
What does that translate to?
To me, that means my intro pitch and credentials are mostly working once I make it to a face-to-face conversation.
Even after making those connections, completing multiple interviews, and reaching the final stages, the process can still stall without a decision or meaningful update for days or weeks.
In the meantime, I've pieced together a 13-hour-a-week freelance role, turned one late-stage corporate rejection into a potential consulting opportunity, and lined up another freelance writing opportunity in my specialty to start by the end of the year.
It's not the permanent position I've been seeking, but it brings in some money and keeps me practicing my craft.
These opportunities have also reminded me that professional relationships can open doors that modern online application systems often leave closed.
The employment report and my spreadsheet aren’t telling contradictory stories. They’re measuring different things. One tracks the labor market. The other tracks what it takes to find a place in it.
The ghosting phenomenon
One of the most frustrating parts of this process is simply not getting a response.
At the initial application stage, I can understand some of it. Employers may receive hundreds of applications for a single opening, and recruiting teams have limited time and resources.
But that doesn't explain the ghosting that happens after someone has reached the interview stage.
In Arkansas, data entry specialist Amanda Lopez shared that after beginning her job hunt in October 2026, she's been ghosted by companies even after sending thank you notes.
"The sitting there wondering while also trying to continue to update our resumes... is frustrating and time consuming," she shared. "I am just trying to stay positive during this time."
Another U.S.-based job seeker, who requested anonymity because he's actively looking for work, sees the imbalance between employers and applicants as a reason to take a different approach.
"This job market is no longer in favor of the seeker," he shared in a message. "The tables have turned and employers are fully aware of the pendulum swinging to their favor."
He believes many employers no longer prioritize the candidate experience. So his response is to focus on volume.
"The more applications I submit, the better my chances of getting callbacks, interviews and ultimately an offer," he said.
That approach also helps him avoid investing too much emotionally in any single opportunity, avoiding some of the pain tied to the punch of being ghosted after a promising interview.
We’re responding to the same uncertainty in different ways. He’s increasing the number of applications. I’ve been trying to increase the chances that mine lead to a conversation.
You have what seems like a productive interview. Maybe two or three. You discuss the position in detail, and someone tells you when to expect an update.
You send a thank-you note.
A week passes. Then another.
You follow up, politely asking whether there’s an update on the hiring timeline.
Nothing.
In journalism, communicating is fundamental to the work -- whether it's reporting, editing, managing teams, or building relationships with sources. The same is true across media and communications.
It doesn’t seem unreasonable to expect an update from an editor or hiring manager who has interviewed you, especially after multiple conversations.
Hiring decisions can be complicated. Timelines change. Budgets shift. A brief message saying so would still be a response.
Every “Thanks, but no thanks” hurts. Rejection can bring self-doubt and second-guessing about your experience and professional worth.
But at least you know. You can thank someone for their consideration, close the loop, and perhaps preserve the relationship.
Ghosting leaves you with many of the same emotions and no clear ending.
Why the ghosting?
No one reason for why this is happening, at least according to those who've explored the trend.
In Texas, fractional operations officer and advisor Paul Miller saw that patterns spread across college interns and new graduates, to senior executives who told him they'd been ghosted after interviews. Some had made it all the way to board level meetings that seemed positive, only to hear nothing afterward.
So, he asked his network of recruiters and hiring managers and a few key points stood out:
- a process that feels "done" once the hire is made
- no clear HR policy
- legal liability on post-interview communications
- hiring decisions stuck with someone who just hasn't decided
- corporate policy changes
Keeping all of that in mind in his operational advising, Miller emphasizes that people remember who ghosted them and that can damage a company's reputation.
"When ghosting is the norm, the companies that close the loop will stand out in a good way. If you've been ghosted after an interview, the company's culture and process are probably the problem, not you."
— Paul Miller. Fractional COO
The hidden cost of 'free' hiring process labor
Another frustration is the amount of work candidates can be expected to complete before they’re offered a job.
I’ve heard stories throughout my professional network about applicants being asked to develop detailed proposals, presentations, or strategic plans as part of an interview process.
My own experience has mostly involved writing tests and on-the-spot news assignments. Some were paid trials. Others were simply expected.
I understand why an employer might want to assess someone’s abilities beyond a résumé or portfolio. But there’s a difference between a reasonable skills assessment and asking candidates to produce substantial work without compensation.
Krystal Hicks, founder and career strategist at JOBTALK, raised this issue in a LinkedIn post about employers requiring finalists to complete presentations or case studies.
"You are not asking... you are requiring," Hicks wrote.
Her point was that candidates often don’t feel free to refuse without jeopardizing their chances, even when an assignment involves original ideas or potentially valuable work.
She argues that employers making these demands should compensate candidates, provide a straightforward nondisclosure agreement intended to protect their ideas, and commit to timely, meaningful feedback.
Her post also included an informal poll asking whether respondents had been ghosted after presenting work during an interview process.
Of 27 respondents, 96% said yes (myself included).
That small, self-selected sample can’t establish how common the practice is. But the responses reflected a frustration I’ve heard repeatedly: Candidates are investing considerable effort without knowing whether they’ll receive even a basic update afterward.
It's another part of the job market that doesn't show up in the monthly federal employment statistics.
A former colleague in the Pacific Northwest, who has also been searching for a full-time role for more than a year, described a similar frustration.
“What strikes me as a common thread these days is that there is a general feeling of a lack of transparency,” he said. “Everyone seems to be guessing and wondering what's going on behind closed doors.”
Replacing cold calls with human connection
One thing this experience has taught me is how much it helps to have people who understand what you’re going through.
Through the Never Search Alone group that I joined in late summer, I've connected with other seasoned professionals navigating layoffs, career transitions, and uncertain hiring processes.
Our industries and backgrounds differ, but many of the challenges sound familiar. Long stretches without responses. Interviews that seem promising but go nowhere. The constant effort to stay motivated while trying to make meaningful professional connections.
Not everyone approaches that challenge the same way.
Josh Propp, an Atlanta-based professional in the energy sector who was on my job search committee in the group, found that a structured approach to networking and accountability helped him move forward.
Laid off earlier this year, Propp joined Never Search Alone as his search began over the summer. He recently started a new job, and he credits much of his progress to building structure and accountability into the process.
"Treating the search like a job made all the difference," Propp said. "I tracked every outreach and follow-up, kept my calendar full of conversations, and made a habit of asking each person I spoke with for 1 or 2 names. That meant every conversation fed the next one, and I always had momentum instead of waiting on replies."
He also learned not to interpret every unanswered message as a lack of interest.
"Following up wasn't an imposition," he said. "It was often the nudge that let someone do something they already wanted to do."
The group also gave him a place to practice before interviews.
"In a traditional search, the first time you articulate your pitch or talk through your trade-offs can be in an actual interview, when the stakes are highest," Propp said.
Working through those questions with a receptive audience helped him narrow his focus and become more decisive about the kind of opportunity he wanted.
After sharing his experience on LinkedIn, Propp heard from several people who were considering career changes but didn't know where to begin. Some were former colleagues, while others were people he'd never met.
None were unemployed or had been laid off.
To Propp, that suggested the approach could benefit people contemplating a career move, not just those actively looking for work.
His experience reinforces something I've seen in my own search: Connecting with people can create possibilities that another online application may not.
It doesn't guarantee an offer or even an interview. My own spreadsheet certainly proves that. But it just might help get a foot in the door, someone flagging your name in an automated system or suggesting you to the hiring manager. It might even help them remember you when another opportunity comes up, before it’s posted online for the world to see.
All of this can make the search less isolating and give us something to work on besides just refreshing the inbox.
Beyond the employment numbers
The October employment report describes a labor market that is still adding jobs, even as millions of people face prolonged unemployment or struggle to find enough work. I’m still searching for a permanent role, and there’s more to that search than the numbers.
My spreadsheet tracks the roles I’ve pursued and where each application stands. It doesn’t show the time spent preparing for interviews or the uncertainty afterward, when I’m trying to decide whether to follow up again or write off another opportunity as lost in a hiring black hole.
Maybe soon, I’ll find myself reflected in a different set of job-market statistics.
Until then, I’m still adding rows to my spreadsheet, betting that one of them will eventually turn into an offer.
- 30 -
